Image credit: AAP
Richmond 9, Collingwood 7
1919 PF: Richmond 10.14.74 def. Collingwood 6.9.45 (MCG)
1919 GF: Collingwood 11.12.78 def. Richmond 7.11.53 (MCG)
1920 GF: Richmond 7.10.52 def. Collingwood 5.5.35 (MCG)
1927 GF: Collingwood 2.13.25 def. Richmond 1.7.13 (MCG)
1928 GF: Collingwood 13.18.96 def. Richmond 9.9.63 (MCG)
1929 SF: Richmond 18.15.123 def. Collingwood 8.13.61 (MCG)
1929 GF: Collingwood 11.13.79 def. Richmond 7.8.50 (MCG)
1930 SF: Collingwood 14.10.94 def. Richmond 14.7.91 (MCG)
1935 PF: Collingwood 14.10.94 def. Richmond 9.12.66 (MCG)
1937 SF: Collingwood 18.12.120 def. Richmond 10.9.69 (MCG)
1969 PF: Richmond 15.17.107 def. Collingwood 12.9.81 (MCG)
1971 SF: Richmond 18.13.121 def. Collingwood 11.11.77 (MCG)
1972 QF: Richmond 25.14.164 def. Collingwood 18.12.120 (MCG)
1973 PF: Richmond 15.15.105 def. Collingwood 14.14.98 (MCG)
1975 EF: Richmond 11.11.77 def. Collingwood 10.13.73 (WP)
1980 GF: Richmond 23.21.159 def. Collingwood 9.24.78 (MCG)
West Coast 3, Melbourne 1
1988 EF: Melbourne 11.7.73 def. West Coast 10.11.71 (WP)
1990 SF: West Coast 19.16.130 def. Melbourne 15.10.100 (WP)
1991 SF: West Coast 17.15.117 def. Melbourne 12.7.79 (WP)
1994 PF: West Coast 16.21.117 def. Melbourne 8.4.52 (WACA)